Best MLS Matches of All Time: Classic MLS Cup and Playoff Games

Relive eight MLS Cup and playoff classics from 1996 to 2022, with the decisive moments, clearly explained results and official places to find highlights or replays.

Best MLS Matches of All Time: Classic MLS Cup and Playoff Games

Start with LAFC and Philadelphia Union in the 2022 MLS Cup final. They drew 3–3 after extra time, then LAFC won the shootout 3–0. The game puts a late comeback, a red card, a substitute goalkeeper and a title on the line in one sitting. If you'd rather see the league's first champion crowned or an underdog turn a playoff tie around, the older games below offer different starting points.

Start with the 2022 MLS Cup final

I chose these MLS Cup and playoff games for what was at stake, how the contest changed as it unfolded, and what a second viewing adds. LAFC and Philadelphia on November 5, 2022 comes first because both teams repeatedly changed what the other needed to do. LAFC had home field at Banc of California Stadium, now BMO Stadium. Philadelphia equalized after Kellyn Acosta's opener and answered again when Jesús Murillo headed LAFC in front in the 83rd minute. Jack Elliott's first goal brought the match back to 2–2 two minutes later. MLS's 2022 final match report

Watch the second half of extra time even if you already know the final score. LAFC went down to ten men when Maxime Crépeau was sent off and hurt in the same incident. John McCarthy came off the bench in the 117th minute. Elliott scored again four minutes into stoppage time of extra time, briefly putting Philadelphia ahead for the first time. Four minutes later, Gareth Bale reached Diego Palacios's cross and headed it in. Both teams had gone through the regulation game and extra time and still had a title to decide from the spot. MLS's account of the extra-time finish

McCarthy's part is especially good to see in sequence. Andre Blake saved LAFC's first penalty. Dániel Gazdag missed Philadelphia's first, and McCarthy saved the next two from José Martínez and Kai Wagner. Ilie Sánchez converted the clincher. LAFC's first MLS Cup also completed a season in which it won the Supporters' Shield. The enduring reason to watch is how many times a moment that seemed decisive became just another play in a game that continued. For the rest of that postseason, see the 2022 MLS playoff bracket and results.

MLS's match video page lists a 4-minute, 11-second highlight reel, separate clips for the late goals and a 2-minute, 14-second shootout recap. Apple TV's U.S. catalog also lists a 2-hour, 59-minute match episode. The highlights fit a short watch. The longer listing gives you a way to find the match buildup and the shifts in pressure if your account offers playback. MLS match video · Apple TV's 2022 MLS Cup episode

The cover shows LAFC's home stadium during a September 2018 match against New England. Archive photo by Bbqnerd, resized and converted under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Three classic MLS Cup finals from different eras

The final score alone gives you little guidance on which match to revisit. The inaugural Cup offers a comeback in the rain and a rule that made one extra-time header end the season. Real Salt Lake's first championship is a reminder of what a club can do from the last playoff place. Seattle's first title turns on one save in a match with no goals during play. Each is a different way for a final to stay close enough for one player to decide it. MLS's historical Cup results

D.C. United vs. LA Galaxy in 1996

October 20, 1996. D.C. United won 3–2 after extra time. The league's first MLS Cup final at Foxboro Stadium was played in heavy rain. Eduardo Hurtado put LA ahead early, and Chris Armas added a second. Tony Sanneh and Shawn Medved brought D.C. level in regulation. In the 94th minute, Marco Etcheverry delivered a corner and rookie defender Eddie Pope headed it in. MLS used the golden goal in that final, so the match finished as soon as the ball went in. MLS on how Pope scored the first Cup winner

This is the best entry here if you want to see an important match on its own historical terms. Watch how the Galaxy use a two-goal lead and how difficult it is to get through the closing part of regulation without conceding again. The rain makes loose balls and restarts worth following. After D.C. ties it, the corner in the first few minutes of extra time carries a different weight because the next goal ends everything. Apple TV's U.S. catalog lists the 1996 match as an episode of 1 hour and 46 minutes. Apple TV's 1996 final listing

Real Salt Lake vs. LA Galaxy in 2009

November 22, 2009. It finished 1–1 after extra time, and Real Salt Lake won on penalties 5–4. Salt Lake had taken the last playoff spot and faced a Galaxy team with David Beckham and Landon Donovan at Qwest Field in Seattle. The two combined on the move that led to Mike Magee's first-half goal. Robbie Findley equalized in the 64th minute. Salt Lake had enough time in regulation to look for a second, and Los Angeles still had to keep the match level through extra time. MLS's match recap

Watch the goalkeeper at each end after the tie gets to penalties. Landon Donovan fired high, and Nick Rimando saved from Jovan Kirovski and Edson Buddle. At the other end, the Galaxy made enough saves to get the shootout to the seventh round. Robbie Russell converted the winner after Rimando's stop on Buddle. For me the final is a better underdog story if you watch Findley's equalizer and the minutes around it as well as the kicks. The league scorebook and the club's recap separately identify the two saves. Apple TV's U.S. catalog has a dedicated match listing. Real Salt Lake's title retrospective · Apple TV's 2009 final listing

Seattle Sounders vs. Toronto FC in 2016

December 10, 2016. It finished 0–0 after extra time, and Seattle won on penalties 5–4. Toronto hosted at BMO Field and Seattle went through the match without a shot on target. The most revealing moment came in the 108th minute. Jozy Altidore's header looped toward the upper corner, and Stefan Frei got across in time to push it away. If you only watch one passage, take in the cross, Altidore's contact and the ball's flight before Frei reaches it. The full sequence shows why the save mattered as a piece of goalkeeping as well as a moment in the title race. MLS on Frei's 108th-minute save

Seattle still had to get through the shootout. Toronto defender Justin Morrow hit the crossbar and Román Torres converted the next kick in the sixth round to win Seattle's first MLS Cup. Frei won the final's MVP award. Watch this if you'd like a low-scoring game in which seeing the chances build, and the defending that kept the score close, makes the ending more meaningful. Apple TV's Canadian catalog lists the match at 2 hours and 23 minutes. MLS's 2016 final recap · Apple TV's Canadian 2016 catalog listing

Seattle midfielder Osvaldo Alonso lifts MLS Cup amid blue and green confetti at the 2016 Seattle victory rally
Osvaldo Alonso raises the MLS Cup at Seattle's December 13, 2016 victory rally. Photo by SounderBruce, resized and converted under CC BY-SA 2.0.

Four playoff games worth revisiting

A conference semifinal can be every bit as absorbing as the trophy game. Keep two numbers in view when you watch a two-leg tie. The scoreboard tells you who is ahead on the night, and the aggregate score tells you who is going through. With a one-game knockout, all of that pressure sits in the match itself. These four games reward different kinds of attention, from following a lead that takes two games to build to watching one side use ten minutes of regulation to change an entire season.

San Jose Earthquakes vs. LA Galaxy in 2003

November 9, 2003. San Jose won the second leg 5–2 after extra time and advanced 5–4 on aggregate. Los Angeles came to Spartan Stadium with a 2–0 first-leg lead and scored twice early in the second. San Jose now needed four goals to extend the series. Jeff Agoos and Landon Donovan scored before halftime, and Jamil Walker scored early in the second half. A team that had looked close to elimination went into the closing minutes needing one more goal merely to get level across the two games. MLS interviews with San Jose players

Chris Roner scored in the 90th minute to make it 4–2 on the night. For all the work San Jose had done to build a lead in the home match, that goal only tied the series. Rodrigo Faria then scored the golden goal in the 96th minute and ended it. The appeal here is the time you have to feel each piece of the recovery. The first San Jose goal restored some hope, the goal after halftime put the Galaxy under real pressure, and the extra-time winner finally gave the Earthquakes the aggregate lead. If you are reading the record instead of watching old footage, the match score and series score are the two figures to write down side by side. MLS's California Clásico retrospective

Portland Timbers vs. Sporting Kansas City in 2015

October 29, 2015. It finished 2–2 after extra time, and Portland won on penalties 7–6. At Providence Park, Rodney Wallace put the Timbers ahead in the Western Conference Knockout Round. Kevin Ellis equalized for Kansas City late in regulation, and Krisztián Németh swung the match Sporting's way in the 96th minute. Portland found a reply through Maximiliano Urruti in the 118th. The shootout gets remembered for good reason, but it took a team coming back in each period of play to get there. Portland's match report and shootout log

Start with the kick by Saad Abdul-Salaam if you only have time for the shootout. His shot hit both posts and stayed out. Hold on after that for the goalkeepers in the 11th round. Adam Kwarasey took Portland's kick himself, converted it and then saved from Jon Kempin at the other end. Kempin had come on for Tim Melia during the match and was Kansas City's goalkeeper by the time the teams got to penalties. The league's match center has separate videos for the highlights and the shootout, an option if you want to see Urruti's late goal before watching the spot kicks. The Timbers eventually won their first MLS Cup by beating Columbus 2–1. MLS match highlights and shootout videos · MLS's 2015 final recap

Toronto FC vs. Montréal Impact in 2016

November 30, 2016. Toronto won the second leg 5–2 after extra time and advanced 7–5 on aggregate. Montréal had gone up 3–0 in the first leg before Toronto scored twice to lose it 3–2. The second leg at BMO Field swung early when Dominic Oduro scored for Montréal. Armando Cooper and Jozy Altidore put Toronto ahead on the night, and Ignacio Piatti drew Montréal level in the match. Nick Hagglund's goal in the 68th minute made it 3–2 to Toronto on the night and 5–5 across the tie. The away-goals rule applied in that round, and by the end of regulation each club had scored twice away from home. That left the clubs even and sent the tie to extra time. MLS first-leg recap · MLS second-leg recap

The match is worth the longer watch because the teams keep answering each other. A short cut to the last two goals misses how exposed Toronto looked after Oduro and why Piatti's reply put the home side under pressure again. In extra time, Benoît Cheyrou replaced Sebastian Giovinco and scored in the 98th minute. Tosaint Ricketts followed in the 100th. That sent Toronto to its first MLS Cup final, where it would host Seattle. Apple TV's U.S. MLS Classics entry for this second leg runs 2 hours and 10 minutes, so check the November date when choosing between this game and the December final. Apple TV's Toronto–Montréal match listing

Seattle Sounders vs. Minnesota United in 2020

December 7, 2020. Seattle won the Western Conference Final 3–2 in regulation. The match took place behind closed doors at Lumen Field. Emanuel Reynoso scored a free kick in the 29th minute for Minnesota and Bakaye Dibassy added a second in the 67th. Seattle brought on Will Bruin and put him up front alongside Raúl Ruidíaz. Bruin gave Seattle a goal and another way to hold the ball near Minnesota's penalty area. Ruidíaz leveled in the 89th minute, and substitute Gustav Svensson headed in Nicolás Lodeiro's corner in the third minute of stoppage time. Seattle's 2020 match report

Look at Seattle's options in the box after Bruin comes on. Minnesota had to track a second forward, and two of the players Seattle sent on eventually scored. The substitutions and the timing give the comeback a shape you can follow in a short video. There is also a link between the two Seattle games in this guide. Osvaldo Alonso, pictured celebrating Seattle's 2016 title above, was in Minnesota's lineup amid Seattle's late push four years later. Seattle's account of the tactical changes · MLS match highlights

Which MLS classic should you watch first?

Pick LAFC–Philadelphia in 2022 if you can make time for one full match. The setting gets you straight into a championship, and the time between the goals tells you as much about the late swing as the scoring itself. If you are watching with someone learning the competition, pick Toronto–Montréal in 2016 next. Start with Montréal's 3–2 first-leg win in mind. When the return leg reaches 3–2 to Toronto, pause and work out why the aggregate score is level. The goals in extra time make more sense once you see how close the series was to taking another turn.

For a short watch, begin with the Portland–Kansas City shootout and then try Seattle–Minnesota's late comeback. The Portland sequence runs from a shot that looks destined for the net to a goalkeeper taking his own kick. The 2020 Seattle highlights let you track the changes around the penalty area, especially the presence of another forward after Bruin joined Ruidíaz. If you are watching for a single save, Frei's extra-time stop in the 2016 final is the choice here. If you have time to sit through the conditions that produced a rare sudden finish, switch to the 1996 final and see how much D.C. had to do to get to Pope's corner.

Check the exact match date and whether the page offers a full replay, highlights or a written account. Toronto played its 2016 home leg against Montréal on November 30 and the final against Seattle on December 10, both at BMO Field. If you want the title match, search the Cup archive by year. If you want the series comeback, search for the November fixture in MLS Classics. The Apple listings linked here are catalog entries for their stated regions. Use the match page's viewing controls to check availability in your account. Apple TV's MLS Cup Matches collection · MLS highlights and replay guide

The playoff schedule is useful once you have watched the older games and want to follow the current bracket. Use the period accounts when watching these eight. A modern bracket won't help you interpret the golden goal in San Jose or the away goals in Toronto. Those rules made the same late scoreline mean very different things to the teams trying to advance. More MLS history · Current MLS playoff bracket and schedule

Join the conversation

Comments

Comments are reviewed before publication.

Spam, abusive content, personal information and policy-violating links are not published.

Loading comments…