Columbus Crew dismissed Federico Higuaín as Crew 2 head coach in late September 2026. The decision followed public scrutiny of an August incident involving a female match official, a two-game MLS NEXT Pro suspension and a referees' union statement criticizing that punishment. Those elements are related in the reporting, but they are not identical kinds of evidence. The dismissal is confirmed by the club; the specific handshake and sexist-comment account is the union's allegation; the club has not published a detailed finding on either allegation.
What the Crew confirmed about Higuaín's dismissal
In its official announcement, Columbus said Higuaín was dismissed from his Crew 2 coaching duties. General manager Issa Tall said the club had held conversations and assessed the previous month, then decided its standards for a team leader had not been met. The release did not identify the specific conduct behind that conclusion or publish an account of the referee's experience. That is an important boundary for any explanation of “why”: the club's public reason is a failure to meet its leadership standard, while reporters connect the decision to the incident and public response.
The announcement also gave a practical next step. Crew 2's existing technical staff would take on added responsibilities for the 2026 MLS NEXT Pro playoffs while the organization searched for a full-time head coach. This was a change to the developmental side's coaching staff, not a change to the Columbus Crew first team's head-coach position. Both teams sit within the same club structure, but they play in different competitions and have different immediate responsibilities.
The Associated Press reported that the club fired Higuaín late on Tuesday, September 22, after allegations involving a female official gained wider attention. AP also observed that the club statement itself did not specifically refer to the August 23 match. That distinction avoids turning a plausible chronology into a quote the Crew never gave. We can say the dismissal came amid fallout from the referee case; we cannot claim the club published the exact internal evidence or deliberations that led to its decision.
The referee incident and response: a dated timeline
The case unfolded in stages over almost a month. A matchday incident and league discipline came first. Public attention rose after the Professional Soccer Referees Association, or PSRA, objected to the penalty; Columbus then made a separate employment decision. Laying out the order helps explain why some reports say Higuaín had already served his suspension before he was fired.
August 23: the Crew 2 match and red card
Axios Columbus reported that the incident occurred after Crew 2's August 23 MLS NEXT Pro match against Huntsville City FC. A red card was issued, and the league opened a review of the reported conduct toward a female official. The public reports describe a postgame encounter, not a routine on-field foul or a disagreement over a particular refereeing decision. Axios also reported that the Crew confirmed to it that Higuaín was the unnamed coach discussed in the PSRA account.
That identification matters because the union's public statement did not name Higuaín. Readers can connect the statement to him through subsequent reporting and the club's confirmation to Axios; the union post alone cannot be quoted as if it identified him. Nor has the club published footage of the encounter or a detailed interview with the official. Those gaps do not undo the league's disciplinary action, but they do set limits on what an outside observer can personally verify.
The two-game MLS NEXT Pro suspension
According to the Columbus Dispatch's September 21 account, MLS NEXT Pro said it investigated the incident, determined that the coach's conduct violated league policy and imposed discipline beyond the red card: a two-game suspension. The league also required participation in a multi-session restorative-practices process. AP reported that Higuaín had already served the two games by the time the dismissal story broke.
The suspension was a league competition sanction. It kept the coach away from two matches under MLS NEXT Pro's disciplinary process; it did not determine whether the Crew must retain him in his employment role afterward. The restorative component was described by the league as already underway, rather than a substitute for the suspension. Public reports do not contain a complete written disciplinary judgment or the evidence weighed in the review, so claims about an exact internal threshold or negotiated reduction need more support than the available record provides.
September 20 to 22: union statement and dismissal
On September 20, PSRA posted its objection to how MLS NEXT Pro handled the case. The union said the two-game punishment sent an inadequate message about the treatment of officials, particularly women. The following day, reports identifying Higuaín and reproducing the league response spread widely. Axios reported supporter calls for dismissal on September 22, before the club announced it had removed him as Crew 2 head coach.
This sequence supports describing the dismissal as occurring amid intense criticism of the incident and sanction. It does not establish that a single social-media post alone caused the firing. The Crew referred to conversations during the week and its assessment of the past month, suggesting a decision process with more information than its short public release disclosed. Without a fuller statement, assigning a private motive or exact moment of decision would go beyond what readers can verify.
What is alleged, admitted and still unclear
Several descriptions of this story circulate with different levels of certainty. The union's account gives the most specific description of the alleged encounter. MLS NEXT Pro publicly acknowledged a policy violation and sanction. Columbus confirmed the coach's identity to a reporter and later confirmed his dismissal. Those statements overlap, but none is a complete public transcript, hearing record or first-person account from every participant.
The PSRA account of the handshake and remark
PSRA alleged that an unnamed male coach squeezed a female official's hand during a postgame handshake and continued holding it after she asked him to stop three times. The union also alleged that he made a remark framing soccer as a man's game. AP's coverage and Axios's local reporting repeat those details as allegations from the referees' association, not as statements independently made in the Crew's dismissal release.
PSRA called the two-game suspension too light for what it characterized as physical intimidation and sexist conduct. That is the union's assessment of the league's disciplinary response. It matters because referees have to work matches with authority and without coercion; a postgame handshake should not put an official in a position where she feels unable to disengage. Still, the publicly available source material does not include a full hearing record, and responsible reporting should avoid promoting the union's exact account into an unqualified finding about every movement or word.
The distinction extends to Higuaín's identification. PSRA did not name him in its original post. Axios said the Crew confirmed he was the coach involved; AP also reported the case as involving him. That reporting supports naming him in this explainer while preserving the origin of each allegation. A reader should not have to guess whether a detail came from the union, the league, the club or a journalist.
What the league and club have publicly said
MLS NEXT Pro's statement, reproduced by the Columbus Dispatch, said it promptly investigated the reported incident, found behavior that violated league policies, added a two-match suspension beyond the red card and required restorative-practices sessions. That is more than a denial that anything happened. It is also less specific than a public finding confirming every word and action in PSRA's description.
Before the dismissal, the Crew said it had worked with the league review and accepted the additional discipline, according to Axios. Afterward, its official release used the broader language of leadership standards and the best interests of players and staff. The shift in organizational action is clear: a league penalty was served, then the employer ended the coaching appointment. What precisely was said in the club's later conversations, and whether Higuaín disputed any detail, is not established by the statements reviewed here. Readers should treat speculative accounts of those private discussions as speculation.
Why the Crew's decision went beyond the league penalty
It can seem contradictory that a coach served the league's two-game ban and was then removed by his club. The two actions answer different institutional questions. MLS NEXT Pro determined a punishment under its competition rules. Columbus had to decide whether the same individual should continue leading its developmental team. An employer can make a staffing decision after a sports sanction has been completed without changing the official record of that sanction.
The club's leadership standard
The Crew's release gives the public rationale in terms of a leadership standard that it concluded had not been met. Tall referred to the interests of the club, players and support staff. In a reserve-team setting, that framing is consequential: the coach is responsible for younger professionals trying to reach the first team and sets an example for how they treat staff, officials and opponents. That responsibility is a reasonable explanation of why the organization would apply its own standard in addition to the league's match ban.
But the public release does not itemize what Tall and others concluded during their conversations. It does not state that they adopted every element of PSRA's account, say whether Higuaín apologized, or disclose a contract provision. Some social posts fill those gaps with confident theories. They are not replacements for the club's own words or documented reporting. The strongest formulation is that the Crew dismissed him after determining he no longer met its expectations for a team leader, amid the fallout from a referee incident.
Why a completed suspension did not settle the matter
By the time the story drew broad attention, Higuaín had reportedly served the two matches and returned to the sideline. The union's September 20 statement then challenged whether the league response reflected the seriousness of its alleged conduct. Axios documented calls from some Crew supporters for a stronger club response. Those reactions form part of the public context, and the club announced its decision soon after. Timing alone does not tell us which factor weighed most heavily internally.
For the players, the important practical difference is who directs the team now. A league suspension would have allowed the coach to return after two matches. Dismissal ends his Crew 2 appointment and shifts playoff preparations to the remaining staff. For officials, the debate over the original penalty remains a broader question about the safety and respect afforded to referees at the development level. Neither outcome should be reduced to a claim that the club simply “extended” the league ban; they are separate decisions with separate decision-makers.
What Higuaín's exit means for Crew 2
This is a notable personnel change because Higuaín was more than a recent outside hire. He had been a popular Columbus player, returned to lead the club's developmental side and was preparing for a postseason. That history explains the attention without excusing or adjudicating the alleged conduct. The immediate consequence is a coaching transition at a time when young players still have competitive matches to play.
His standing as a Crew player and development coach
When Columbus appointed Higuaín ahead of the 2025 MLS NEXT Pro season, it emphasized his eight seasons in the club's colors, 55 regular-season goals and a then club-record 63 assists. It also cited his experience coaching Inter Miami CF II. The appointment was intended to connect a familiar former first-team player with the next group of prospects. That explains why this was a difficult and highly visible decision for the organization, rather than an anonymous change in a reserve-team dugout.

His playing legacy remains a matter of record, but it does not decide whether he should lead a team today. A developmental coach is judged on the environment he creates, alongside results and player progress. The alleged treatment of an official therefore concerned more than one emotional postgame exchange: it raised questions about the behavior young players observe from a senior figure. The Crew's release points to a leadership standard, though it does not specify exactly how the club evaluated each allegation.
The immediate coaching plan and broader referee issue
The Crew said its remaining technical staff would carry extra duties through the 2026 MLS NEXT Pro playoffs while it searched for a permanent replacement. The release offered no named interim head coach or hiring timetable. Readers following Crew 2's results should look for a later club announcement before treating any staff member as the confirmed long-term successor. The change does not, by itself, remove the team from the competition or alter its playoff qualification.
Beyond Columbus, PSRA's statement asked whether the league's disciplinary response adequately protects officials, particularly women. The union and MLS NEXT Pro plainly disagreed about the sufficiency of a two-game ban and restorative process. The public dispute is about standards and trust as well as one coach. That does not mean new league policy has already been announced or that every allegation has been established in a public hearing. As of September 26, the clear next questions are whether the league or club releases more information and who takes the Crew 2 job permanently.
Frequently asked questions about the Higuaín case
These answers reflect public statements and reporting available through September 26, 2026. A later club, league or union update could change the status of an appeal, a coaching appointment or a disciplinary review. For now, the safest way to understand the case is to distinguish the three organizations involved and the dates on which each spoke.
Was Higuaín fired from the MLS first team?
No. Columbus's announcement specifically dismissed him as Crew 2 head coach. Crew 2 competes in MLS NEXT Pro, the developmental league associated with MLS clubs. The statement assigns added duties to the Crew 2 technical staff for its playoffs and says the club will search for a full-time coach for that side. It does not announce a change to the Columbus Crew first-team coaching position. Confusing the two teams can exaggerate the immediate sporting effect of the decision.
Did the referees' union name him in its statement?
No. AP noted that PSRA described an unnamed male coach. Subsequent reporting identified Higuaín, and Axios reported that the Crew confirmed he was the coach discussed. This distinction matters when quoting or paraphrasing the union: its detailed account is its allegation about an unnamed coach, connected to Higuaín by reporting and club confirmation to a journalist, not by the wording of the union post itself.
Has a public appeal or further sanction been announced?
The inspected club release confirms the dismissal and replacement search, while the reported league response identifies a served two-game suspension and restorative-practices requirement. As of this September 26 review, these sources do not document a later appeal outcome or additional MLS NEXT Pro suspension. That is a limit of the public record reviewed here, not a guarantee that no private process exists. A future official announcement should take precedence over this dated summary.
The case remains a useful reminder that coaches, referees and clubs operate under overlapping responsibilities. A match sanction, a union challenge and a club employment decision can follow the same incident without representing the same judgment. For the latest Crew 2 leadership status, the club's own announcements are the primary source.
Comments
Comments are reviewed before publication.
Spam, abusive content, personal information and policy-violating links are not published.
Sign in with Google to comment or reply.
Loading comments…